ODOT hides environmental impacts of highway projects
The following is a
During the next decade, the Ohio Department of
Many of these projects will cut through prime farmland, forest, streams and other natural resources and wildlife habitat. ODOTs road expansions also will exacerbate sprawling development, especially around metropolitan areas.
Remarkably however, ODOT is largely evading required environmental reviews of its massive road expansion program by segmenting many projects into small pieces. Shorter projects usually have fewer significant environmental impacts, which is the threshold for detailed environmental review under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA). Dividing large road projects into shorter pieces reduces the significance of the impacts, and therefore the need for full environmental review. Segmentation distorts the transportation planning process by fragmenting statewide and regional transportation issues into artificially smaller pieces, circumvents the environmenal review process, and masks the true environmental impacts of larger projects.
In this report, the Environmental Law & Policy Center (ELPC) explains ODOTs pervasive pattern of segmentation of major road construction projects. The report includes five case studies where ODOT has avoided serious environmental review for major highway corridors,
The five road projects discussed in this report include:
1. U.S. Route 30 across Ohio. ODOT already has constructed substantial portions of this high-way without performing detailed environmental reviews, and ODOT is planning to construct seven additional segments of four-lane highways along the corridor without performing any detailed corridor-level environmental review.
2. Interstate 71 between Cleveland and Columbus. ODOT is planning to expand more than 75 miles of this major north-south highway to three lanes in each direction without performing any review of the sprawl-inducing consequences of increasing the highways capac-ity by 30 percent. ODOT segmented this project into four pieces, thereby allowing ODOT to evade a detailed regional review of the environmental impacts of the expansion.
3. U.S. Route 24 in Northwestern Ohio. By dividing the so-called Fort to Port highway project into three pieces, ODOT avoided a systemic evaluation of the regional environmental and transportation impacts of the costly expansion project.
4. U.S. Route 33 Southeast of Columbus. ODOTs segmentation of this highway project into at least four segments means that ODOT will never systematically
5. State Routes 161, 37 and 16 from New Albany to
ODOTs systematic avoidance of NEPA requirements has serious negative environmental and transportation planning consequences. Farmland, forest, wetlands, wildlife habitat and other irreplaceable natural areas suffer greater losses. Fragmented planning leads to poor long-term transportation decision making. And new road construction
Back to Citizen's Transportation Plan
Full text of the Environmental Law and Policy Center's report on ODOT (Acrobat PDF file, 360 KB)
ODOTs systematic avoidance of NEPA requirements has serious negative environmental and transportation planning consequences. Farmland, forest, wetlands, wildlife habitat and other irreplaceable natural areas suffer greater losses. Fragmented planning leads to poor long-term transportation decision making. And new road construction becomes the default choice, even though other alternatives such as regional passenger rail might offer better, more cost-effective solutions for the State.