National law group analyzes
policy implications of HB 218

Ohio House Bill 218 deals with the location of shoreline land
ownership boundaries around the Ohio portion of Lake Erie. This bill is currently being considered in the Ohio Senate. In an effort to allow more informed decision making and allow everyone to better understand the legislation, Frank Lichtkoppler, a Sea Grant Extension agent in Ohio, requested that the National Sea Grant Law Center in Mississippi review and comment on the proposed legislation. That review, written by Stephanie Showalter, J.D., M.S.E.L., follows below.

See a complete version of this review with footnotes (48 KB Word document).

Public access to Lake Erie threatened
A controversial bill pending before the Ohio State Legislature, if passed as introduced, would shift the upper boundary of Ohio's Lake Erie public trust lands from the ordinary high water mark to the low water mark. Brought this matter to our attention and asked us to share our thoughts.

The Public Trust Doctrine
Under the common law, the public trust doctrine provides that "public trust lands, waters and living resources in a state are held by the state in trust for the benefit of all the people, and establishes the right of the public to fully enjoy public trust lands, waters and living resources for a wide variety of public uses." Public trust waters are the state's navigable waters and public trusts lands are the lands beneath those navigable waters, up to the ordinary high water mark. Public trust lands include tidelands, shorelands, and the land beneath oceans, lakes, and rivers.

Public trust lands are unique in that two separate titles exist to the same piece of land. The state holds the public title, often referred to as jus publicum, ensuring the right of the public to use and enjoy the public trust waters and lands for commerce, navigation, fishing, bathing, and other related uses. The jus publicum interest is reserved by the state regardless of the deed. "

A state cannot convey the jus publicum interest into private
ownership, nor can it abdicate its trust responsibilities."2 The private title, the jus privitum, can be held by a private individual or the state.

The holder of the private title has the right of use and possession. The private right to use the public trust lands, however, is subservient to the dominant public right of access.

Ohio's Public Trust Doctrine
Each State manages its public trust lands and waters in different and unique ways. Ohio is a high water state, which means that the state owns both titles, the private right to possess and the public "trust" title, from the shore up to the high water mark.

Section 1506.10 of the Ohio Code establishes Ohio's rights to the waters of Lake Erie. It states that the waters of Lake Erie... extending from the southerly shore of Lake Erie to the international boundary line between the United States and Canada, together with the soil beneath and their contents, do now belong and have always, since the organization of the state of Ohio, belonged to the state as proprietor in trust for the people of the state.

The Ohio Supreme Court has stated that "the state as trustee for the public cannot by acquiescence abandon the trust property or enable a diversion of it to private ends different from the object for which the trust was created."

House Bill 218
When introduced, House Bill 218 contained language that would clearly violate the public trust doctrine. The drafters of the bill sought to alter § 1506.10 by placing the words "natural low water mark of the" before "southerly shore" and adding a paragraph restricting the state's property interest to below the natural low water mark. As mentioned above, a state may not transfer all ownership rights to public trust property to private owners. A shift in the boundary line from the high water mark to the low water mark would improperly divert public trust property from public to private use.

It appears other members of the Ohio House realized the problems with the bill's language. The bill now reads "the waters of Lake Erie...extending from where the waters of Lake Erie make contact with the land to the international boundary...belong to the State."

With the alteration in language, even if the bill passes, the authority of the Ohio Department of Natural Resources and the rights of the public should be preserved. While the version of the bill passed by the House could still be interpreted as granting private property rights above the low water mark, Ohio courts are more likely to adhere to precedent and set the high water mark as the line where Lake Erie makes contact with the land.

It is still too early to tell whether the panic caused by the introduction of this bill was premature. While passage of the bill could greatly affect the state's coastal management program, H.B. 218 has significant hurdles to overcome before adoption. The bill is currently pending in the Ohio Senate, which may not be as susceptible to the political pressure applied by Lake Erie property owners as representatives in the House. Due to the significant public access implications of H.B. 218, the Law Center will continue to track this legislation as it moves through the Ohio Legislature and/or the courts.

Source: Volume 2, No. 4 The SandBar
Legal Reporter for the National Sea Grant College Program
University of Mississippi

Sea Grant Law Center
Kinard Hall, Wing E Room 262
P.O. Box 1848
University, MS 38677-1848

Back to top

EcoCity Cleveland
3500 Lorain Avenue, Suite 301, Cleveland OH 44113
Cuyahoga Bioregion
(216) 961-5020
Copyright 2002-2003

Back to main HB 218 page

A state may not transfer all ownership rights to public trust property to private owners. A shift in the boundary line from the high water mark to the low water mark would improperly divert public trust property from public to private use.

go to home page Togel Online Situs Togel Terpercaya daftar 10 nama situs togel terpercaya situs bo togel 5 bandar togel togel178 pedetogel sabatoto togel158 pragmatic178 novaslot88 Situs Togel Terpercaya Togel178 Togel279 Toto Macau Situs Togel Bandar Togel Agen Togel Bo Togel Daftar Togel Togel279 Toto Macau Toto Togel Sabatoto Sabatoto Sabatoto Togel279 Togel Online Slot88 Situs Togel Prize 123 Bo Togel Terpercaya Togel Online Daftar Akun Togel Resmi Toto Macau Toto Togel Situs Togel Terpercaya Situs Togel Via Pulsa Tanpa Potongan Daftar Togel Via Pulsa Tanpa Potongan Togel BBFS 10 Digit Situs Togel Bonus New Member Situs Togel Togel Pulsa Situs Togel Daftar Situs Togel Situs Togel Terpercaya Situs Judi Togel Slot Olympus Toto Togel Slot 4D Toto Slot 4D BO Togel Terpercaya Slot Mahjong Bet 200 Slot Nuke Gaming BO Togel Hadiah 2D 200rb BO Togel Hadiah 2D 100rb BO Togel 4D Daftar Akun Togel Resmi Togel Gopay Toto Togel 4D Bandar Togel Togel Deposit Linkaja Togel Terpercaya Situs Togel Bri Online 24 Jam Situs Bandar Togel Situs Agen Togel Situs BO Togel Situs Togel Resmi Toto Bandar Judi Togel Daftar Bandar Togel Situs Togel Diskon Daftar Togel Toto Situs Togel Prize 123 Situs Togel Resmi WLA 5 bandar Togel Togel IDN APK Togel Togel Dana Togel Ovo Link Slot Gacor Group BO Togel Situs Judi Togel Online24jam Terpercaya Togel Bebas Invest Slot Anti Rungkat Dadu Sicbo Toto Togel Togel Bet 100 Aplikasi Togel Togel Dana Bo Togel Toto Slot togel e-wallet Togel Online 10 situs togel terpercaya daftar akun togel resmi Pasaran Togel Toto Togel 10 situs togel terpercaya Situs Togel Terpercaya togel online Situs Bo Togel BBFS 10 Digit Kumpulan Situs Togel Link Alternatif Togel Toto situs togel terpercaya prize 123 link alternatif togel terpercaya Situs Togel Bet 100 Perak Daftar Situs Togel Via Dana slot luar negeri Bo Togel Hadiah 2D 200rb Togel Resmi Bandar Togel 4D Aplikasi Togel Situs Togel Deposit Via Ovo Bandar Togel Terbaik situs togel bri online 24 jam Situs Togel Terpercaya Kumpulan Situs Togel Terpercaya Situs Togel Terpercaya Situs Togel Bandar Togel Terbesar Situs Togel Prize 123 Situs Togel Terpercaya Daftar Agen Togel Resmi Aplikasi Togel Terpercaya Situs Togel Terbesar Agen Togel Terpercaya Rekomendasi Bo Togel Terpercaya Togel Resmi WLA Situs Togel Deposit 10rb 10 Situs Togel Terpercaya Togel Bbfs Situs Togel Bet 100 Perak Situs Togel 4D situs togel 8 situs togel terpercaya 5 bandar togel slot demo mahjong aplikasi togel link togel group situs togel situs togel terpercaya judi togel bo togel hadiah 2d 100rb toto macau aplikasi togel bo togel bolak balik bandar togel daftar akun togel resmi togel dana togel pasaran toto togel situs bandar togel BO TOGEL situs togel resmi bo togel terpercaya Slot Luar Negeri bo togel hadiah 2d 200rb Bo Togel Hadiah 2d 100rb bo togel bo togel bolak balik acak dibayar bo togel resmi Dadu Sicbo Online 10 situs togel terbesar situs toto togel 10 situs togel terpercaya daftar akun togel resmi slot demo pragmatic situs judi togel terbaik dan terpercaya no 1 demo slot pg soft pedetogel togel178 togel279 togel158 sabatoto novaslot88 pragmatic178 toto macau roulette online Casino Live slot kamboja togel dana togel bbfs 10 digit togel bebas invest togel e-wallet togel pasaran togel dan slot bandar togel toto macau toto macau resmi toto togel 4d togel dana toto macau 4d Toto Slot agen togel toto togel togel dana cara membuat akun togel di hp android cara pasang togel togel diskon terbesar togel luar negeri togel prize slot nuke gaming toto macau Situs Togel Terpercaya Link Togel Terpercaya Daftar Togel Slot Olympus Slot PG Soft Bandar Togel Hadiah 4D 10 Juta Terpercaya Toto Macau Toto Togel Bandar Togel Terpercaya Toto Macau Togel 4D Situs Togel Via Dana Rekomendasi Togel Terpercaya Daftar Bandar Togel Togel Resmi Terpercaya Situs Togel Bayaran Tertinggi Kumpulan Situs Togel Terpercaya Situs Togel Bet 100 Perak Rekomendasi Togel Terpercaya Situs Togel Bet 100 Perak Situs Togel Terlengkap Judi Togel Online Slot Luar Negeri Toto Macau Togel Via Pulsa Togel Online situs togel bo togel judi togel aplikasi togel bo togel hadiah 2d 100rb situs bandar togel Toto Togel 10 Situs Togel Terpercaya Togel Via Dana Toto Macau Togel Online Toto Togel